Cochinita Pibil cooked in a Pit

La Verdadera Cochinita Pibil
Recipe from Season 5, Mexico—One Plate at a Time 1.  Dig the pit.   The day before, find a flat area in your backyard that's not too near your neighbors with no low hanging tree branches. Measure and stake out an area that is about 8 inches larger all around than the pan you are planning to use, and about 8 inches deeper.  For this recipe, the roasting pan I use is a heavy gauge aluminum roaster that measures about 21 x 17 1/2 x 7 inches; it's made by Vollrath and can be purchased at most restaurant supply companies.  If your pan matches mine, you'll be measuring and staking out a rectangular pit that's 37 x 33 inches. Dig the pit to an even depth of 16 inches, working to keep the sides straight and even all the way down.  Keep the excavated dirt in a pile beside the pit. Next, line the bottom of the pit with bricks, fitting them tightly together, then line the sides up to the top, packing the bricks tightly against the earthen sides. 2.  Build the fire(s):  To warm up the bricks and ground around them (and also to "season" a newly dug pit), build a bonfire in the pit for 7 hours or so the day before you cook the cochinita pibil. Early on the day of cooking, build another huge fire in the pit and let it burn for about 5 hours, adding logs regularly to keep the temperature up at around 700 or 800 degrees. (If you put your hand near the edge of the fire, it should be so hot that you'll have to withdraw it instantly.)  About 2 hours before you'll be putting in the pig, stop adding wood; let the fire burn down to ash-covered embers.  Set the steel or corrugated metal sheet beside the pit.
Servings: 35people for a hearty dinner


  • For the Pit
  • Tape measure, stakes and string for mapping out the pit area
  • Shovel (and lots of energy)
  • Bricks
  • A steel or corrugated metal sheet to cover the pit
  • For the Pig
  • 35pound pig (you'll probably have to get yours directly from a pig farmer or an ethnic market; you can ask to have it cut into primal cuts: front quarters, legs, saddle halved down the backbone, head) OR 35 pounds of bone-in pork shoulder (Boston butt) roasts
  • 54-ounce packagesachiote seasoning (El Yucateco is a commonly found brand)
  • 2 1/2cups fresh lime juice
  • 31-pound packagesbanana leaves, defrosted
  • Pickled red onions, for serving (recipe below)
  • Habanero salsa, for serving (recipe below)


  1.  Marinate the pig. Line your roasting pan with 2 packages of banana leaves leaving a 6-inch overhang on all the edges. Fit the pieces of pork into the bottom of the pan.Prepare the marinade by breaking the achiote bricks into pieces, dropping them into a blender jar, adding the lime juice and 1 tablespoon salt; blend until the mixture is a smooth thickish marinade. Pour the achiote mixture over the pork, spreading it evenly to coat all surfaces (I recommend you wear latex gloves, since achiote will strain your hands red).
  2. Cook the pig. Fold the overhanging banana leaves in over the pork, then use the last package of banana leaves to cover the pork completely. Pour about 3 quarts of water over the leaves - it will collect in the bottom of the pan and should be about 1 inch deep.Wearing heavy oven mitts, lower the pan into the very hot pit (this will take two people); the water should immediately begin boiling in the bottom of the pan. Cover the pit with the steel or corrugated metal sheet, and immediately begin piling the excavated dirt around the edges of the sheet to prevent any oxygen from entering the pit. (You have to do this carefully and completely, since any oxygen leaks will cause the fire to continue burning - which typically leads to a burnt pig. It's the intense amount of residual heat in the brick-lined pit that cooks the pig.) Once the edges are sealed, spread all leftover dirt evenly over the pit-covering sheet.Typically, a 35-pound pig needs 4 to 6 hours to cook to fall-off-the-bone tenderness.
  3.  Serve the pig. When you've decided to take the plunge and unearth the pig, clean the dirt off the steel or corrugated sheet, then, wearing heavy oven mitts, remove it. Lift out the roasting pan full of pig and stop for a moment to savor the aroma. When you peel back the banana leaves, and press in a thermometer, the fork-tender meat should be between 150 and 165 degrees if your pit was at the right (scorching-hot) temperature.I like to carry the pan to the kitchen, remove the meat, pull meat from bone, coarsely shredding it into baking pans, and then slide all the meat, covered with foil, into a low oven, until I'm ready to serve (it will hold for an hour or two). I set the huge roasting pan on the stove over high heat (on all burners) and boil the juices until they're as rich as I like (usually I reduce them by half their original quantity). Taste and season with salt.Serve with meat on a big, deep, beautiful platter with pleanty of steaming hot corn tortillas, black beans, pickled red onions and habanero salsa.

Pickled Onions
Cebollas Curtidas
Makes 7 cups

4 large (about 1 1/2 pounds) red onions, peeled and cut in half
2 cups fresh lime juice

Thinly slice the onions (this can be done using a food processor fitted with a thin slicing blade). Scoop the onions into a heat-proof, non-reactive bowl. Pour boiling water over them, wait 10 seconds, then pour the onions into a large strainer. Return the drained onions to the bowl, pour on the lime juice and stir in the 1 1/2 teaspoons salt. Cover and place in the refrigerator until serving time. Before serving, taste and season with additional salt if you think necessary.

Habanero Salsa
Salsa de Chile Habanero
Makes about 1 cup

24 habanero chiles, stems removed
6 garlic cloves, unpeeled
1 1/2 cup fresh lime juice

Set an ungreased skillet or griddle over medium heat. Lay in the unpeeled garlic and the chiles. Roast, turning frequently, until soft and blotchy brown in spots, about 5 minutes for the chiles, 10 to 15 minutes for the garlic. Cool until handleable, then slip the skins off the garlic.

Place the garlic in a food processor. With the motor running, drop in the chiles one after another. When all are in, continue processing for about 20 seconds, then add the lime juice, 1 1/2 teaspoos salt and 1/4 cup of water. Continue processing until smooth; the habanero salsa should be the consistency of an American hot sauce.


  1. I have a question for the Slow-Roasted Yucatecan Pig in a Pit. If I wanted to make just 1 or two how would I go about doing that? Your recipe is for 35 people I just have 5 guest for dinner. Please let me know how to cut your recipe in half.
    Ms. Marion Burris

  2. I’ve seen where instead of a thick marinade its more of a thicker juice that coats the meat & cooks in the juice instead of been steamed by the water. How do i get that consistency and retain great flavor

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *